Geoffrey try murdered when you look at the a biking crash into the 1186 and Constance married (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, 4 th Earl out-of Chester, toward 3 rd March 1188, inside the a married relationship put up by Queen Henry 11. This matrimony deteriorated and you can Ranulph imprisoned Constance inside the 1196. Rebellions have been stimulated across Brittany on the and Ranulph put out their unique inside the 1198. Back into Brittany, Constance got her wedding annulled and later from inside the 1198, she got Guy de Trips because the their particular ‘second’ spouse.
Constance died old forty, (possibly out of leprosy, possibly after giving birth to dual girls) towards the 5 th September 1201 during the Nantes
Even though this wasn’t a consanguineous dating but one of attraction, people earliest-knowledge relationship would have made marriage anywhere between Constance and you can any kind of John’s brothers hopeless as opposed to a good dispensation –– hence because of the party’s score would have had to are from the pope themselves
The theory that Constance had an event which have John adopting the loss of Geoffrey and you may in advance of John’s matrimony so you’re able to Isabella away from Gloucester during the 1189, which she was mother so you can Joanna is extremely controversial and provides provoked much discussion inside genealogical groups.
You to definitely review out of good genealogist says you to ‘the latest diary ‘The Plantagenet Connection’ has actually blogged a keen ahnentafel out-of Age Plantagenet, wife of Henry V11, gives Joanna’s mother’s identity as the Constance (perhaps misnamed Clemence?), Duchess off Brittany. This is actually the Constance who was simply John’s aunt-in-law! Considering the really-understood animosity between John and you can Constance and her individual attempts to push their particular son Arthur’s appeal in terms of the newest throne away from England try worried (and we the understand how disastrously one to turned-out!), I truly discover advised matchmaking a little tough to take. The brand new Constance you to definitely record depicts doesn’t struck me personally since the on just who John could easily coerce towards the sleep.’
‘ A principle who would pick Joanna’s mother because Constance does not account fully for a highly critical reason for canon laws. Who would indicate that particular trace of the matter have to certainly came down to us, whether it inside brand new obtain they, the brand new deliberations, or even the actual dispensation in itself https://kissbrides.com/brazilian-women/florianopolis/. As far as i in the morning alert, absolutely nothing of one’s form can be obtained.’
Of the only which have sex that have John, aside from impact him a baby, Constance will have based an initial-training matchmaking from attraction with all John’s sisters –– including John’s sibling Geoffrey
My own viewpoint for what it’s worthy of, is that had Constance become mom away from Joanna she’d seriously enjoys delivered their particular up in her household and her identity would be too also known as Constance’s almost every other people by Geoffrey (Eleanor, Fair Housemaid out-of Brittany, Matilda/Maud of Brittany and you may Arthur).
Agatha was given birth to on 1168 from inside the Chartley Palace, Staffordshire. It’s well known one she try a mistress of John and lots of nearest and dearest woods give their, no matter if solitary, since mom of Joanna. Very genealogists yet not are convinced that it is only supposition you to definitely this woman is Joanna’s mom since no facts or ideas exist to display which.
One to supply seem to provided try Sir William Dugdale, on Baronage out of England (1675-6). He says their resource become Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s work is an expanded model out-of H Lloyd’s interpretation from ‘The latest Historie off Cambria’ of the 12 th century Saint Caradoc off Llancarfan. Another supply, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ of the Charles Browning, copyright 1969 also labels Agatha de- Ferrers, daughter regarding Robert de- Ferrers, 4th Earl away from derby, given that Joanna’s mom.
Even in the event she cannot be completely dismissed as an applicant having mom off Joanna, undoubtedly there is some shadow from her into the a great chronicle or any other historic site, in the event the she had in reality started mom of the wife of new Prince of North Wales.